• TRM (USD/COP)COP 3,461.92 +1.37% +COP 46.82Colombia's official exchange rate (Financial Superintendence), valid Nov 21 to Nov 23
  • EuroCOP 3,804.64 +1.37% +COP 51.45Reference: TRM crossed with the European Central Bank rate of Nov 20; not the market quote
  • Mexican pesoCOP 181.56 +1.37% +COP 2.45Reference: TRM crossed with the European Central Bank rate of Nov 20; not the market quote
← Back to the community
General

Why are retailers rejecting Visa and Mastercard's swipe-fee settlements to force network routing competition?

Federal court rejections of Visa and Mastercard's thirty-billion-dollar swipe-fee settlement alongside the Department of Justice's debit monopolization lawsuit prove that temporary interchange rate caps cannot fix U.S. payment rails as long as the Honor All Cards rule and tokenization lock-in block independent network routing.

When U.S. District Judge Margo Brodie struck down the proposed settlement in the two-decade Payment Card Interchange Fee antitrust litigation—sending the case toward trial remedies before Judge Brian Cogan—she agreed with major retailers and the Merchant Payments Coalition that shaving a few basis points off credit card swipe fees was paltry compared to the more than $100 billion American merchants pay annually in interchange. Because Visa and Mastercard centrally set default interchange schedules for thousands of issuing banks and enforce strict 'Honor All Cards' rules, retailers cannot refuse high-fee premium rewards cards from JPMorgan Chase or Capital One without losing acceptance of basic consumer cards.

Simultaneously, the Department of Justice's antitrust suit against Visa's $2 trillion debit business exposes how volume-tier pricing cliffs and proprietary network tokenization have blunted the Durbin Amendment's Regulation II mandate, which requires at least two unaffiliated routing networks on every debit card. By locking online transactions into proprietary tokens, dominant card rails prevent merchants from routing payments over lower-cost PINless networks like Star, NYCE, and Shazam.

Will federal antitrust courts and the Credit Card Competition Act finally force multi-network routing onto U.S. credit cards, or would slashing swipe fees simply kill consumer airline and cashback rewards?

How should U.S. credit and debit card interchange fees be reformed?

0 votes

Comments

Be respectful. Comments reported by several people are hidden until a moderator reviews them.

You do not need an account to read, only to comment. Sign in with a code sent to your email or with your Google account. We only show the name you choose, never your email.