Grupo Cibest (NYSE: CIB) vs. Nu Holdings (NYSE: NU): Who Wins Colombia's 30% ROE Banking War?
Following its corporate restructuring into Grupo Cibest (NYSE: CIB) and the $1.42 billion Banistmo divestiture, Bancolombia has lifted its annualized ROE to 28.7% and NIM to 7.94% to defend its COP 264 trillion deposit base against Nu Holdings (NYSE: NU) and its 31%–33% ROE.
In SEC Form 20-F filings and domestic reports supervised by the Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia (SFC), Grupo Cibest (BVC: CIBEST) pairs a COP 256–262 trillion loan book (94%–95% loan-to-deposit ratio) with Nequi's 27 million accounts. Meanwhile, Nu Holdings scales past 5 million customers in Nu Colombia through high-yield 'Cajitas' savings, backed by $41.9 billion in global retail deposits, a $39.4 billion credit portfolio (+37% YoY), and a 22.9% risk-adjusted NIM powered by NuFormer AI underwriting.
As the Banco de la República holds its benchmark policy rate at 12.25% and expands the Bre-B instant payment rail alongside SFC Open Finance APIs, customer switching costs have collapsed across Colombia. Will Grupo Cibest protect its low-cost deposit moat through Nequi and corporate lending, or will Nu Holdings capture retail credit alpha as rates normalize?
Comments
Be respectful. Comments reported by several people are hidden until a moderator reviews them.
You do not need an account to read, only to comment. Sign in with a code sent to your email or with your Google account. We only show the name you choose, never your email.